AI Search Strategy

Today’s Agency Model Is Broken. Here’s What AI Search Needs Instead

Marketing leaders told us the agency model isn't working. In AI Search, the gaps get worse. Here's why, and what a model built for AI Search looks like.

The short answer

The traditional agency model was built for a slower era: human-only bandwidth, long handoffs and reporting on activity instead of outcomes. AI Search makes those gaps worse, because AI answers change constantly and the work spans strategy, technical fixes, content and authority. What works better is service-as-a-software: AI-native software doing much of the work, with specialists directing and reviewing it, measured in business results.

Key Takeaways

  • Swapping one agency for another rarely fixes the problem, because the model itself is the constraint.
  • AI Search needs constant measurement and frequent updates, which manual workflows struggle to deliver.
  • Many agencies add AI Search to an SEO retainer and work it like SEO.
  • Service-as-a-software pairs AI-native software with human expertise and reports business results.

What Did 300 Marketing Leaders Tell Us?

At SaaStr, we spoke with more than 300 marketing leaders: CMOs, founders and operators responsible for pipeline and performance. We expected a mix of views. Instead, we heard the same thing again and again: the agency model doesn’t work anymore.

They weren’t complaining about one bad agency or one bad campaign. They were describing something structural. And most of them didn’t know there was another option.

Why Doesn’t Switching Agencies Fix It?

For decades, the fix for disappointing results was the same: fire the agency, hire another one. Over time, the pattern became clear. The problem isn’t which agency you choose. It’s the model. Even strong agencies tend to share the same structure:

  • Long onboarding before work starts
  • Overhead from project management and status meetings
  • Human-only bandwidth, which limits how much can get done
  • Infrequent reporting that arrives after decisions are made
  • A focus on activity delivered, not outcomes achieved

AI Search raises the bar on all of those gaps. AI answers change constantly, so the data and strategy need frequent refreshes. The work spans technical fixes, strategy, content and authority across the web, so it can’t live in one silo. And success is measured in presence, citations and leads, not in hours or deliverables.

Many agencies respond by adding AI Search, often called AEO or GEO, to an existing SEO retainer and working it like SEO. That’s why bolt-on AEO fails. In-house teams face their own version of the problem: too few people, too many priorities and no dedicated AI Search specialist.

Is It a Talent Problem?

No. This isn’t about weak agencies or underperforming marketers. The agency model was designed for a different era, before AI-native tools, real-time data and the pace buyers move at today. If execution feels harder than it should, you’re not imagining it. You’re working inside a model that wasn’t built for this.

What Does a Better Model Look Like?

We call it service-as-a-software: AI-native software does much of the work, and specialists direct and review it, delivered as one service. Applied to AI Search, that means:

  • Software that connects every stage, from audit and technical fixes to strategy, content and measurement
  • AI agents trained on your business that handle research, drafting and tracking
  • Specialists who review every step and own the strategy
  • Reporting on business results: AI presence, citations, AI referral traffic and leads

It’s the model Soarion is built on. See how it works, or read the service-as-a-software definition in our glossary.

What Should You Ask Before Choosing a Partner?

Whether you’re evaluating an agency, a monitoring tool or a complete solution, ask who builds the strategy, who does the work, how often the data refreshes and how results are measured. Our guide to choosing an AI Search partner lists the questions to ask.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why Is the Agency Model Broken?

Because it relies on human-only bandwidth, long handoffs and activity-based reporting. Those limits slow execution and make it hard to tie work to outcomes, especially in fast-changing channels like AI Search.

What Is Service-As-A-Software?

A model where AI-native software does much of the work and specialists direct and review it, delivered to clients as one service rather than a tool they run themselves.

Can My SEO Agency Handle AI Search?

Some can, but many add AI Search to an SEO retainer and work it like SEO. Ask how they build AI Search strategy, fix technical issues for AI and measure presence, citations and leads.

Is an In-House Team Better Than an Agency for AI Search?

It can be, if the team has dedicated AI Search expertise and time. Most marketing teams don’t, which is why many work with a partner instead.

How Should an AI Search Partner Report Results?

On AI presence and citations by buyer question, share of voice against competitors, AI referral traffic and the leads it drives, measured in your own analytics.

Brittany Trafis
About the author

Brittany Trafis

Brittany Trafis is Co-Founder and CEO of Soarion Digital and has spent more than 20 years advancing technology and marketing. She writes about AI Search as a new channel beyond SEO, and how brands become the answer as buyers move to AI.

LinkedIn
Get started

Ready to Become the Answer in AI Search?

Start with a free AI Search Presence Report, delivered in two business days, or book a demo to see how Soarion would work for your brand.